Beyond Home-Cookin' and the Waltons
Sometimes the “localist" movement is criticized for being based on nostalgia for times past. It is true that there's some recognition that we've gone too far in the wrong direction and need to turn back to get on the right track. There is also a tendency to look askance at the ugliness and monotony inherent in chain stores and sprawl compared to old-fashioned village centers and downtowns. And maybe there's a longing in there for our grandmother's soup or reworked hand-me-downs, and an appreciation of the skills required to produce them. It's true that there is some backward glancing, but I think it's based firmly in the present - with an eye to the future.
In a recent interview in the World Ark, interviewer Lauren Wilcox asks Wendell Berry if he thinks the main problem with the long distances between producer and consumer is the isolation - the lack of community - it creates for the consumer. His response: “No, the main problem is the permanent depletion of resources.”
This seems true to me, and it's worrisome. And it’s why the idea living locally goes way beyond "lifestyle" or a nostalgic wish to live like “the Walton’s” or Little House on the Prairie” or like any story or dream of the past. We’re running out of the resources that made the American dream of unending growth and ever-expanding “wealth” possible. And we're already beginning to suffer the consequences.
Many pretty smart people believe that we are near or past our peak of global oil production (peak oil), and that from here on out it’s only going to get scarcer and way more expensive. There are a lot of smart people, too, who are noting that the effects of climate change are happening at a faster pace than projected just a few years ago. Either of those two things have the potential for radical change in our economic and agricultural situation. Both together are likely going to be devastating to our "lifestyles" and to the very lives of the world's poor.
Poor quality food shipped long distances, the emptiness of consumerism, the loss of farmland to suburban sprawl - all of these things can and do strike a chord of nostalgia for a very recent past when people lived much closer to the source of their needs and didn't seem to "need" as much. Wendell Berry is right. Our ways have isolated us and created an impoverished way of life, the loss inherent in which leads many of us longing for “the good old days.” But the real problem is that it’s not sustainable.
We can begin to change willingly now. Or we can wait until disaster – more wars for oil and other resources, high food prices, expensive fuel, and a crashing economy force us to change. We're trying to take steps toward living a more responsible life now. I wonder, though, if we should be jogging.












